1. Home
  2. Dairy
  3. American cheese
  4. Pan-frying

Classic grilled cheese sandwich

Adam Ragusea · ♥ 87K likes · 3.7M views · 9 min video

Read about american cheese in the BrightCulinary Book

Timestamp
Ingredients
Method
Techniques
  • softened butter
Soften the butter at room temperature, or microwave cold butter at low power 10 or 20 seconds, flip, and give it another quick hit; not melted, just spreadable.
The three-ingredient grilled cheese
  • 2 slices white factory-made pre-sliced sandwich bread
Butter one side of each slice of bread generously.
Why so much butter
Heat a pan, non-stick preferred, over medium heat; put the first slice in butter side down.
Building and covering the sandwich
  • 2 slices American cheese
Lay on two slices of American cheese and a little dusting of garlic powder; top with the second slice butter side up.
  • garlic powder
Cover with a lid or foil, not airtight, so steam melts the cheese; check often since the sugary bread burns fast.
Flip when dark and crispy, cover again until side two is brown, then give a few final flips uncovered to get both sides hot and crispy.
  • mayonnaise
Variation: slather mayonnaise instead of butter; do not cook it as brown as the butter version.
Butter versus mayonnaise blind test
Cut into triangles.
  • rye bread
  • 1 slices real sharp cheddar
  • 1 slices Swiss
  • water
Variation: rye bread with a slice of sharp cheddar and a slice of Swiss and garlic powder; for real cheese, add a little water to the pan halfway through and seal with a tight lid so steam makes the cheese stretchy.
Rye bread grilled cheese with real cheese